Safekipedia

Contract with America

Adventurer · ages 7–10Adapted from Wikipedia
Official portrait of Newt Gingrich, a United States Congressman who served in the House of Representatives in the 1990s.

Do not confuse this with Contract from America. The Contract with America was a plan that the Republican Party supported during the 1994 congressional election campaign. Newt Gingrich and Dick Armey wrote it. Parts of it used words from former president Ronald Reagan's 1985 State of the Union Address. The contract listed things Republicans promised to do if they became the majority party in the United States House of Representatives for the first time in 40 years. Many of its ideas came from the Heritage Foundation, a conservative think tank.

The Contract with America was shared six weeks before the 1994 congressional election. That election was the first midterm election during President Bill Clinton's administration. Almost all of the Republican members of the House signed the contract. So did the party's Republican candidates who were not already in Congress.

The contract explained the plans of the Republican members of Congress. It was meant to make the election a matter for the whole country. Its ideas matched the views of many conservative Republicans. They wanted a smaller government, lower taxes, and changes to tort reform and welfare reform.

The 1994 elections went well for Republicans. They gained 54 seats in the House and 8 seats in the U.S. Senate. This gave them control of both chambers. Party leaders such as Minority Whip Newt Gingrich, Dick Armey, and the American conservative movement saw the contract as a big success.

Content

The contract listed eight reforms that the Republicans promised to make. It also listed ten bills that they promised to bring up for debate and votes, if they became the majority after the election. The authors only included "60% issues." These were ideas that polls showed had 60% support from the American people. This helped the contract avoid hard topics like abortion and school prayer. Reagan biographer Lou Cannon said that more than half of the contract's text came from a speech by Ronald Reagan, the 1985 State of the Union Address.

The eight reforms included making laws that apply to the rest of the country also apply to Congress. They also wanted a major, independent auditing firm to check Congress for waste, fraud, or abuse of money. Other promises were cutting House committees and their staff, and banning proxy votes in committee. The Republicans also wanted a three-fifths vote to pass a tax increase. They promised an honest federal budget using zero base-line budgeting.

During the first one hundred days of the 104th Congress, the Republicans promised to bring ten bills to the floor for full debate and fair votes. These bills mainly covered a balanced budget, tax cuts for small businesses, families, and seniors, term limits for lawmakers, social security reform, tort reform, and welfare reform.

Implementation

See also: Term limits in the United States

When the 104th Congress met in January 1995, the Republican majority tried to carry out the Contract with America. The contract promised ten bills to reform the federal government. Members debated them and voted on them. Some bills became one law. Others were split into several laws. Most of the bills did not pass the Senate. A plan to change the Constitution to require a balanced budget passed the House but was rejected by the Senate. A plan to limit how long members of Congress could serve was also rejected, by the House. Several crime bills passed the House. They included changes to truth in sentencing, the death penalty, and money for prisons. The Personal Responsibility Act passed both houses, but President Clinton vetoed it. A similar plan, the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act, became law in 1996. It changed the Aid to Families with Dependent Children program.

Other bills dealt with United Nations peacekeeping, NATO, "loser pays" laws, and product liability. Some of these bills passed the House but were stopped later. The Private Securities Litigation Reform Act, a tort reform bill, became law in 1995. Congress passed it after overriding Clinton's veto. Bills for small businesses and rules on regulation also passed the House. They included changes to the Regulatory Flexibility Act and unfunded mandate rules. One of them required that cost-benefit analysis be checked by the Office of Management and Budget and reviewed by the Congressional Budget Office. A tax package with a child tax credit and Earned Income Splitting also passed the House. Mark Hatfield, a Republican senator from Oregon, and Bob Dole both took part in the Senate debate on the balanced budget amendment.

Non-implementation

In a November 2000 article, Edward H. Crane, the leader of the libertarian Cato Institute, said that the budgets of 95 major programs had gone up by 13%. The Contract with America had promised to get rid of these programs.

Effects

Some observers say the Contract with America helped the Republicans win a big victory in the 1994 elections. Others disagree and point out that it was introduced late in the campaign. Either way, Republicans won a majority in both houses of Congress for the first time since 1953, and some parts of the contract became law. Most parts did not pass Congress. Others were vetoed by, or greatly changed in talks with President Bill Clinton. Clinton jokingly called it the "Contract on America," suggesting the Republicans' plan was like a organized-crime "hit" on the American public.

The authors of The Right Nation argue that the contract put Congress back in charge of national policy for most of the 104th Congress. They say it left the Clinton White House on the defensive. George Mason University law professor David E. Bernstein has said the contract showed that Congress took federalism and limited national government seriously. He also argued that it made the Supreme Court decision in United States v. Lopez more likely.

Commentary

Journalist and senior congressional reporter Major Garrett compared the contract to a game of miniature golf. He said it was a fun and popular activity meant to please middle-class voters. It was not the serious work of running the country.

Republicans he talked to while the contract was being written said it was meant to be a political document with easy goals. It was not a plan for governing. One senior aide said, "We don't care if the Senate passes any of the items in the contract. It would be preferable, but it's not necessary. If the freshmen do everything the contract says, they'll be in excellent shape for 1996."

In 2014, business and finance writer John Steele Gordon wrote in The American, an online magazine published by the American Enterprise Institute. He praised the contract. He called it the main reason Republicans won in 1994, partly because it "nationalized the election."

Quiz time!

4 questions about Contract with America

Question 1 of 4

Who wrote the Contract with America?

Pictures

Newt Gingrich speaking at a town hall event in Derry, New Hampshire, in January 2012, during his presidential campaign.

Keep exploring

This article is a child-friendly adaptation of the Wikipedia article on Contract with America, available under CC BY-SA 4.0.

Images from Wikimedia Commons. Tap any image to view credits and license.