Safekipedia

Proton decay

Adventurer · ages 7–10Adapted from Wikipedia
A chart showing how scientists' experimental limits on proton decay have changed over time, compared with what theories predict.

For the type of radioactive decay in which a nucleus ejects a proton, see [Proton emission. For the radioactive decay where a proton within a nucleus converts to a neutron, see positron emission.]

This article is about the idea that protons could break apart, which is called proton decay. Scientists study it to learn whether stability of matter and baryon number are always kept. They have been interested in it for a long time, both in theory and in experiments. Breaking baryon number is one of three key ingredients needed to explain why there is more matter than antimatter in the Universe. Andrei Sakharov first described this idea in 1967.

Diagram of a proton decay into a positron and a neutral pion (p → e+ + π0)

Even with a lot of effort, proton decay has never been seen. The best current limit says a proton lives at least 2.4×1034 years, if it decays into a positron and a neutral pion. According to the Standard Model, the proton is stable because baryon number is conserved. Protons are the lightest baryons in this model, so they cannot decay into other particles by themselves. Positron emission and electron capture are types of radioactive decay where a proton becomes a neutron. They are not proton decay, because in these processes the proton interacts with other particles inside the atom.

Grand Unified Theories (GUTs) allow baryon number to be broken, so protons could decay through the Higgs particle, magnetic monopoles, or new X bosons. The half-life would be between 1031 and 1036 years. For comparison, the universe is roughly 1.4×1010 (14 billion) years old. That is at least twenty orders of magnitude smaller. These very long times are hard to test, but watching about 1034 protons each year could detect average lifetimes of 1034 years. About 1034 protons fit in around 30 kton of water, a little more than the detector volume of the most sensitive experiment running now, Super-Kamiokande.

The easiest decay to detect is into a positron and a neutral pion, which many GUT models predict. It leaves a very clear signal with no hidden particles, so scientists can work out the proton's mass from the products. Supersymmetric versions of GUT models favor a harder-to-spot pathway. Scientists can look for the muons made when kaon particles decay at rest, and for the gamma rays given off when a nucleon decays inside an oxygen nucleus. Other processes, such as neutron-antineutron oscillations, can also help experiments test baryon number conservation.

History

In the Standard Model of particle physics, matter stays stable because of a rule called baryon number. Hermann Weyl suggested this idea in 1929. Ernst Stueckelberg formally described the conservation law in 1939. In the 1950s, scientists found that the limits on how long a proton could last were extremely long. In 1981, the first limit was published by a water detector at the Homestake gold mine. Many experiments began in the early 1980s, including some in Japan.

Scientists hoped they could test proton decay because of Grand Unified Theories. These theories predicted that protons could decay at energies that special experiments could reach. The KamiokaNDE experiment, led by Masatoshi Koshiba, was finished in 1983 in the Kamioka zinc mine. It used a large tank of pure water with about 1,000 photomultiplier tubes, which detected Cherenkov light. KamiokaNDE set strict limits that ruled out the simplest Grand Unified Models. Its much larger successor, Super-Kamiokande, was built between 1991 and 1996 and holds about 17 times more water. Later, two Nobel prizes for neutrino physics were given for work done with detectors that were first built to look for proton decay.

Planned experimental searches

Scientists are still asking whether protons decay. If they do, how long would it take? Can nuclear binding energy affect this? More unsolved problems in physics

A new, much larger detector called Hyper‑Kamiokande is being built now. It will be about 5.2 times as massive as Super-Kamiokande and about 8 times larger in the space where it detects particles. It is planned to start collecting data in 2028. After 10 years, it should be able to spot proton decay 3 to 5 times better than Super-Kamiokande.

Evolution of the experimental limits on the decay channel (left) and on the decay channel (right), compared with predictions from different GUT models, shown in different levels of grey. The first two points of the left plot are historical inclusive searches; references are in the text.

Other important experiments will also search for proton decay. JUNO in China started collecting data in January 2026, and DUNE in the US is planned to start in 2031. All three projects were first proposed mainly to study neutrinos, but they can still search for proton decay very carefully. The table below summarizes this.

The time evolution of the experimental limits for two proton decay channels is shown in the plot below, along with the predictions of different theoretical models.

Current and projected limits on the proton decay lifetime (90% confidence level) in different decay channels
ModePresent Limit (1034 yr)Projection (1034 yr)
p → e+ π0>2.4 (Super-K)>7.8 (Hyper-K)
p → ν̄ K+>0.59 (Super-K)>3.2 (Hyper-K);
>1.3 (DUNE);
>1.9 (JUNO)
p → μ+ π0>1.6 (Super-K)>7.7 (Hyper-K)

Theoretical motivation

Scientists have proposed Grand Unified Theories (GUTs). These theories try to join the forces described by the Standard Model into one bigger non-Abelian group, under a single gauge coupling. In these theories, electric charge comes out naturally from the bigger group. The most likely way a proton would break down in these theories is p → e+ + π0. Three running coupling constants of the Standard Model support the idea of GUTs. They connect to the electromagnetic (hypercharge), weak interaction, and strong interaction. They follow renormalization group equations. At low energies, the strong interaction becomes stronger (asymptotic freedom below about 1 GeV), while the other two become weaker. Because of this, all three come close together at about 1015 GeV. This is the natural energy level for GUTs. For a broader overview, see Grand Unified Theory.

Evolution of the running coupling constants as a function of energy computed with the Standard Model parameters (left panel) and the Minimum Supersymmetric Standard Model (right panel)

SU(5) was introduced in 1974 by Georgi and Glashow. It is the simplest way to join the forces into one group. It gives a fairly exact prediction for how long a proton lasts, about 3.2⋅1029 ± 1.3 years. This prediction came from a 1981 calculation using the values known at that time. Other versions, such as SO(10), can give different predictions. Adding Supersymmetry, where every particle has a partner, makes the three forces meet at one point. It also predicts a longer proton lifetime. However, it allows other ways for protons to break down, so extra rules are added to limit them. Flipped SU(5), Split SUSY, and versions using supergravity or extra dimensions are other ideas that scientists have studied. Results from the LHC have strictly limited some of the predictions of Supersymmetry. Experiments may not be able to rule out every possible model. However, they can test most of the predicted proton lifetimes.

Proton decay predictions in various GUT models
ModelModesτp (years)
Minimal SU(5)
p → e+π01030 − 1031
Minimal SUSY SU(5)
p → ν̄K+
n → ν̄K0
1028 − 1034
Minimal SO(10)p → e+π01032 − 1036
SUSY SO(10) (std. d = 5)
p → ν̄K+1033 − 1034
Flipped SU(5)
p → e/μ+π01035 − 1036
Split SU(5) SUSY
p → e+π01035 − 1037
SUGRA SU(5)
p → ν̄K+1032 − 1034
SU(5) in 5 dimensions
p → μ+K0
p → e+π0
p → ν̄K+
1034 − 1035

1036 − 1039
GUT-like models from Type IIA string with D6-branes
p → e+π0~ 1036

Decay operators

In the SU(5) theory, a proton can decay when three quarks and a lepton interact by exchanging a very heavy X boson. These interactions break the lepton number rule and the baryon number rule. However, they keep the combination B − L balanced. In minimal supersymmetric standard models (MSSM), another kind of interaction is possible. Two quarks from a proton can join to form a virtual squark. The squark then breaks apart into a lepton and another quark. This could make protons decay far too quickly. So scientists would need a new rule, called R-parity, to block these interactions. This rule also makes the lightest supersymmetric particle a possible candidate for dark matter.

Even with R-parity, some other interactions can still allow a proton to decay. One example is decaying into a kaon and a muon neutrino. To predict proton lifetimes longer than 1034 years, the MSSM model must be adjusted carefully.

Quiz time!

4 questions about Proton decay

Question 1 of 4

Have scientists ever seen a proton decay?

Pictures

A Feynman diagram showing one way a proton might decay, a process physicists study to test theories about the building blocks of matter.

Keep exploring

This article is a child-friendly adaptation of the Wikipedia article on Proton decay, available under CC BY-SA 4.0.

Images from Wikimedia Commons. Tap any image to view credits and license.