Alaska boundary dispute
The Alaska boundary dispute was a territorial dispute between the United States and the British Empire over the Canada–United States border in Alaska. It took place between the 1890s and 1900s. For the ongoing sea dispute between Yukon and Alaska, see Beaufort Sea § Border dispute. Canada was then a British dominion, so the United Kingdom was responsible for negotiating with the American government about the dispute. The disagreement over the border had existed since 1825, between Britain and Russia.
After the United States acquired Alaska from Russia in 1867, the Canada–Alaska border continued to be disputed. The argument grew stronger after the 1897 Klondike Gold Rush in Yukon.
Anglo-American negotiations eventually led to the dispute being settled by arbitration in 1903. The final decision favored the American position. Canada did not get an all-Canadian route from Yukon's gold fields to the Pacific Ocean.
News of the outcome was met with widespread anger in Canada. Many Canadians felt that the British government had betrayed them by putting better Anglo-American relations ahead of Canadian interests.
Background
In 1825, Russia and the United Kingdom signed the Anglo-Russian Convention of 1825 to set the borders of their colonies. The agreement said the line would run north along Portland Channel to the point where it reached the 56th degree of north latitude, then follow the mountains near the coast to the 141st degree of west longitude. If those mountains were more than ten marine leagues from the ocean, the line would run parallel to the coast and never be more than ten leagues away. This was a general agreement for the future, not an exact line. In 1839, the RAC–HBC Agreement gave the Hudson's Bay Company a strip of the Alaskan Panhandle, from Cross Sound to 54°40′, as a fur trade monopoly. In return, the company gave farm and herding products from its subsidiary, the Puget Sound Agricultural Company, and a yearly amount of furs to the Russian-American Company. The lease was renewed until the end of Russian America. The United States bought Alaska from the Russian Empire in 1867 in the Alaska Purchase, but the boundary terms were unclear. In 1871, British Columbia joined the new Dominion of Canada. Canada asked for a survey of the border, but the United States said it was too costly, since the area was remote, sparsely settled, and of no economic or strategic interest. In 1898, the national governments agreed on a compromise, but the government of British Columbia rejected it. U.S. President McKinley proposed a permanent lease to Canada of a port near Haines, but Canada rejected that compromise too.
The Klondike Gold Rush in 1897–98 in Yukon, Canada, greatly increased the population of the area, which reached 30,000, mostly Americans. About 100,000 fortune seekers moved through Alaska to the Klondike gold region. A village grew from 500 people in 1896 to about 17,000 by summer 1898. Gold and the large new population made the region more important and made an exact border more important. Canada wanted an all-Canadian route from the gold fields to a seaport. There were reports that Canadian citizens were harassed by the United States to discourage them from making any land claims. The head of Lynn Canal was the main gateway to the Yukon, and the North-West Mounted Police (NWMP) sent a group to secure it for Canada, based on Canada's claim that the spot was more than ten marine leagues from the sea. A huge influx of American stampeders through Skagway quickly forced the Canadian police to retreat, and they set up posts on the bare summits of Chilkoot and White Passes. Many Americans believed the border should be at the head of Lake Bennett, about 12 miles (19 km) farther north. To back up the police, Canada also sent the Yukon Field Force, a 200-man Army unit, which camped at Fort Selkirk so it could quickly respond to problems at the passes or the 141st meridian west.
Arbitration
See also: Dixon Entrance
The posts that the NWMP set up on the passes worked well for a short time, and the temporary boundary was accepted, though not gladly. Serious talks between the United States and Canada began in September 1898, but those meetings failed. The 1825 treaty had been written in French, so British advocates argued over the exact meaning of words such as "côte/coast," "lisière/strip," and "crête/crest." The maps of George Vancouver showed a continuous line of mountains running parallel to the coast, but the mountain range is neither parallel nor continuous. In 1903, the Hay–Herbert Treaty between the United States and the United Kingdom gave the decision to a six-member tribunal: three Americans, Elihu Root, Henry Cabot Lodge, and George Turner; two Canadians, Sir Louis A. Jette and Allen B. Aylesworth; and one Briton, Baron Alverstone. Aylesworth had replaced John D. Armour, who died in London on July 11, 1903, while working on the boundary commission. Canadians made fun of the choice of Turner and, especially, Lodge, whom they saw as unfair.
The tribunal looked at six main questions, including where the boundary began, what "Portland Channel" meant, and whether mountain ranges existed in the area. Lord Alverstone sided with the U.S. position on these basic issues. The agreed line was a compromise between the largest U.S. and Canadian claims. The "BC Panhandle" (Tatshenshini-Alsek region) was not quite exclaved from the rest of British Columbia. In 1929, Canadian scholar Hugh L. L. Keenlyside wrote, "The Americans, of course, did have the better case." He felt that most of the tribunal's decisions were fair, but he criticized the decision on the islands in Portland Channel, where the line was drawn through Tongas Passage and each country received part of its claim. This was one of several concessions Britain offered the United States, as part of a wider effort to improve relations (the Great Rapprochement).
Growth of a distinct Canadian identity
Historians Keenlyside and Brown wrote that if the United States had agreed to take its case to The Hague, or to an impartial court of judges as Canada wanted, the result would probably have been much the same. The difference was that Canadians would not have felt treated unfairly. If judges from the United States Supreme Court had been chosen instead of the two senators, Canadians would not have criticized the award so loudly. The Canadian judges refused to sign the award, issued on 20 October 1903, because the Canadian delegates disagreed with Lord Alverstone's vote. Canadians were upset mainly because the Americans had chosen politicians instead of judges, and because the British had put better Anglo-American relations ahead of Canadian interests.
This led to anger at Britain across Canada and a rise in Canadian nationalism, meaning a sense of identity separate from the British Empire. Suspicion of the United States caused by the award may have played a part in Canada rejecting free trade with the United States in the 1911 "reciprocity election". Historian F. W. Gibson concluded that Canadians directed much of their anger at Great Britain for offering such weak resistance to American aggressiveness. Prime Minister Wilfrid Laurier told Parliament that while Canada remained a dependency of the British Crown, its powers were not enough to protect its rights. Canadian anger later faded, but the feeling that Canada should control its own foreign policy may have helped lead to the Statute of Westminster.

Quiz time!
5 questions about Alaska boundary dispute
Why did the United Kingdom, rather than Canada, handle the talks with the American government about the border?
Pictures
Keep exploring
This article is a child-friendly adaptation of the Wikipedia article on Alaska boundary dispute, available under CC BY-SA 4.0.
Images from Wikimedia Commons. Tap any image to view credits and license.