Nanjing Massacre
The Nanjing Massacre was a terrible event in which Japanese soldiers killed Chinese civilians, people who were not fighting, and prisoners of war. It took place in Nanjing, the capital of the Republic of China, which was formerly romanized as Nanking. The killings happened between December 1937 and March 1938, right after the Battle of Nanjing and the retreat of the National Revolutionary Army during the Second Sino-Japanese War. The Imperial Japanese Army carried out the massacre.
Before reaching Nanjing, the Japanese had moved quickly through China after capturing Shanghai in November. As they advanced, they committed violent atrocities, including killing contests and the massacres of entire villages. By early December, the Central China Area Army, led by General Iwane Matsui, reached the edge of the city. Prince Yasuhiko Asaka was the temporary commander, and he ordered troops to "kill all captives" before the city was captured. Matsui and Asaka took no action to stop the massacre once it began.
The massacre began on December 13, 1937, after Japanese troops entered the city. Japanese soldiers murdered civilians, including children, women, and elderly people. Japanese units also summarily executed thousands of captured Chinese soldiers, as well as male civilians who were falsely accused of being soldiers. Women and girls were attacked, and about one third of the city was destroyed by fire. Many scholars support the findings of the International Military Tribunal for the Far East, which estimated that more than 200,000 people were killed. Other estimates vary, but the massacre is considered one of the worst wartime atrocities in history.
An International Committee of Westerners, including Nazi German citizen John Rabe, created the Nanking Safety Zone to try to protect civilians. The Safety Zone was mostly a success and is credited with saving at least 200,000 lives.
After the war, Matsui and several other commanders at Nanjing were found guilty of war crimes and executed. Asaka was granted immunity as a member of the imperial family and was never tried. The massacre remains a contentious topic in Sino-Japanese relations, because Japanese nationalists and some top government officials have denied or minimized it.
See also: Battle of Nanjing
The Second Sino-Japanese War began on July 7, 1937, after the Marco Polo Bridge incident. It quickly grew into a full war in northern China. The National Revolutionary Army did not want a decisive battle in the north, so it attacked Japanese forces in Shanghai instead. Japan sent an army led by General Iwane Matsui to fight them. In August 1937, the Japanese army invaded Shanghai, where they met strong resistance and suffered heavy losses in close, hand-to-hand combat. The Japanese forced the Chinese to retreat. Tokyo first chose not to expand the war, but Matsui wanted to advance on Nanjing, believing that capturing the Chinese capital would bring the Nationalist Government down and win the war quickly. Tokyo eventually agreed to the attack.
In a press release, Tang Shengzhi said the city would not surrender and would fight to the death. His garrison of about 81,500 soldiers included many untrained conscripts and troops worn out from the Battle of Shanghai. The Chinese government left the city on December 1, and the president left on December 7. The city's administration was handed to an International Committee led by John Rabe, a German citizen and Nazi Party member. Rabe, who chaired the Nanking International Safety Zone Committee, boarded the USS Panay (PR-5) on December 9 to seek permission from Chiang Kai-shek for a ceasefire. On December 11, Rabe found that Chinese soldiers were still in parts of the Safety Zone, which made it a target for Japanese attacks even though most people there were innocent civilians. Efforts to remove the soldiers failed, and Japanese soldiers began to lob grenades into the refugee zone.
March to Nanjing and atrocities
Although the massacre is generally described as taking place over six weeks after the fall of Nanjing, the crimes of the Japanese army began earlier. As the army advanced from Shanghai to Nanjing, many terrible acts were committed, including killing, burning, and other crimes against civilians. Many were part of a terror campaign meant to break the will of the Chinese population to resist. Japanese commanders ordered their troops to treat Chinese people outside Shanghai as enemies and to destroy their homes. A hamlet near Wuxi was set on fire, and in Jiading, many civilians were killed after the town was shelled. On December 8, the Japanese captured Zhenjiang, set the city on fire, and it burned for ten days.
Main article: Nanking Safety Zone
Many Westerners were living in Nanjing at that time, and most of them fled as the Japanese army approached, leaving 27 foreigners. Fifteen of the remaining 22 formed a committee to create a safe area in the western part of the city. German businessman John Rabe, a member of the Nazi Party, was elected as its leader. The Japanese government had earlier agreed not to attack parts of the city without Chinese military forces, and the committee persuaded the Chinese government to move its troops out of the area. Christian missionary Minnie Vautrin worked to shelter thousands of women at Ginling Girls College, which was inside the safety zone. Danish man Bernhard Arp Sindberg and a German colleague turned a cement factory into a refuge for thousands of Chinese civilians.
Civilian population and evacuation
With the capital of China moved away, constant bombing raids, and reports of Japanese brutality, many of Nanjing's people had fled out of fear. Wealthy families were the first to leave, travelling by car. The middle class left next, and then the poor. Those who stayed were mainly the poorest people, such as the ethnic Tanka boat people, and people with belongings that could not be easily moved, like shopkeepers.
Nanjing had an estimated population of over one million before the Japanese invasion. A large part of it had already fled before the Japanese advance, an estimated half (500,000) to three-quarters (750,000) of the pre-war population.
"Plan B": the intended use of poison gas and incendiary bombing in Nanjing
On November 30, the Japanese Tenth Army drew up two plans for attacking Nanjing. Plan A was a fast rush into the city. If that failed, Plan B called for using incendiary bombs and mustard gas canisters to "reduce the city to rubble." The plan said the city should be surrounded and bombed from the air for about a week, and it described poison gas as "imperative" in the attack.
Japanese commanders had also planned to use mustard gas and incendiary bombs on the Chinese capital if the fighting became as fierce as the Battle of Shanghai. Historian Bob Wakabayashi commented that such a plan would have resulted in "a holocaust for one city."
Battle of Nanjing
Main article: Battle of Nanjing
The Japanese army kept moving forward, broke through several Chinese lines, and reached the city gates of Nanjing on December 9. The Chinese defenders fought hard, but they suffered more and more losses, and the Japanese had stronger firepower and more soldiers. Tiredness and broken communications made it hard for the city's defenders to hold on. Over the four-day battle, they were slowly overwhelmed and finally collapsed on the night of December 12.
On December 12, under heavy artillery fire and bombing from the air, General Tang Sheng-chi ordered his men to retreat. Confusing orders and a breakdown in discipline turned the retreat into a disaster. Some Chinese units escaped across the river, but many others were caught up in the chaos across the city. Some Chinese soldiers took civilians' clothing to try to blend in, and many were shot by a Chinese supervisory unit as they tried to flee. On December 13, Japanese divisions, including the 6th and 114th, were the first to enter the city. That same afternoon, two small Japanese Navy fleets arrived on both sides of the Yangtze River.
The Nanjing Massacre
From early December 1937, the Japanese Army carried out random killings, looting, arson, and other war crimes in the Nanjing area. These crimes grew much worse after Nanjing was captured on December 13, and they continued for several weeks. The first three weeks were the most intense. Attacks on people lasted for several months, both inside the city walls and in the countryside, until a new ruling government was set up on March 28, 1938.
A group of foreign expatriates headed by Rabe formed a 15-member International Committee for the Nanking Safety Zone on November 22. They mapped out the Nanking Safety Zone to protect civilians in the city.
Causes
Several factors helped cause the Nanjing Massacre. Japanese people were taught racist and militaristic ideas, and the Japanese government's fascist beliefs spread the idea that Japanese people were superior to all other peoples. Japanese soldiers were treated cruelly by their commanders and were hardened by the difficult fighting in China. Japanese society also held attitudes that showed contempt for women. The violence in Nanjing was part of Japan's wider invasion of China, including the 1937 Shanghai–Nanjing Campaign, and it grew out of a deep contempt for other Asians that was common in Japanese society before the war.
Former Japanese soldier Shiro Azuma said in a 1998 interview that Japanese soldiers were taught they were a superior race, and that they held nothing but contempt for the Chinese. Many soldiers also took out their anger on civilians after months of fighting. Jennifer M. Dixon, an associate professor at Villanova University, said the Battle of Shanghai was longer and harder than the Japanese had expected, which led to a desire for revenge. Prime Minister Fumimaro Konoe justified the massacre as retaliation against the Kuomintang. Historian Richard B. Frank linked the violence to attitudes toward women in Japan. Jonathan Spence, a British-American sinologist and historian, wrote that there is no obvious explanation for this terrible event.
Matsui's reaction to the massacre
On December 18, 1937, General Iwane Matsui began to understand the full extent of the terrible crimes in the city, which included violence, killing, and looting. He grew increasingly dismayed. He told one of his civilian aides that he felt deeply sorry for the tragedies suffered by the people. On New Year's Day, he told a Japanese diplomat that his men had done something very wrong and extremely regrettable.
Matsui blamed the atrocities on the moral decline of the Japanese Army. He called the Nanjing Incident a terrible disgrace and said he had wept tears of anger in front of the higher officers. He felt that all the efforts to build the empire's reputation had been lost in one moment because of the soldiers' brutality.
End of the massacre
In late January 1938, the Japanese army forced all refugees in the Safety Zone to return home, and immediately claimed to have "restored order." After the establishment of the weixin zhengfu (Chinese: 维新政府; pinyin: Wéixīn zhèngfǔ) (the collaborating government) in 1938, order was gradually restored in Nanjing, and atrocities by Japanese troops lessened considerably.
On February 18, 1938, the International Committee for the Nanking Safety Zone was forcibly renamed the Nanjing International Rescue Committee, and the Safety Zone effectively stopped functioning. The last refugee camps were closed in May 1938.
Recall of Matsui and Asaka
In February 1938, both Prince Asaka and General Matsui were called back to Japan. Matsui went into retirement. Prince Asaka stayed on the Supreme War Council until the war ended in August 1945. In August 1939, he was promoted to the rank of general, but he did not hold any more military commands.
Evidence collection
After Japan's surrender in 1945, Japanese military and government officials destroyed or hid many important documents before American troops arrived. In 2003, the director of Japan's Military History Archives said that as much as 70 percent of Japan's wartime records were destroyed. Some of the hidden information about the Nanjing Massacre did not come out until decades later. A two-volume collection of military documents was published in 1989, and parts of the diary of Kesago Nakajima, a commander at Nanjing, were published in the early 1980s. Historians such as Edward J. Drea and Yang Daqing of George Washington University have studied this destruction of records.
Other sources also helped reveal what happened. Bernhard Arp Sindberg, an amateur photographer, took photos of the massacres and the destruction in the city and smuggled his film out of China. Ono Kenji collected wartime diaries from Japanese veterans, and nearly 20 of them were published in 1994. In 1984, Kaikosha, the Japanese Army Veterans Association, interviewed former soldiers who had served near Nanjing. Many of them confirmed that the massacre took place, and in 1985 the association apologized to the people of China. Honda Katsuichi, a Japanese journalist, concluded after interviewing Chinese survivors and reviewing Japanese records that the massacre was not an isolated case. Since the 1980s, the Chinese government has supported research to collect evidence of the massacre.: 155
Death toll estimates
Main article: Death toll of the Nanjing Massacre
It is hard to know the exact number of people who died. Japanese military officials destroyed many wartime records, Japanese soldiers disposed of many Chinese bodies, and some people in China and Japan have changed the facts to fit their own views. Still, the most credible scholars in Japan support the findings of the International Military Tribunal for the Far East, which estimated more than 200,000 casualties. Japanese historian Tokushi Kasahara estimates "more than 100,000 and close to 200,000, or maybe more," and he says the number could be higher as more information is found. Tomio Hora estimated at least 200,000 deaths. Canadian historian Bob Wakabayashi counted 109,475 Chinese deaths in December 1937 alone, including 46,215 men whom Japanese forces murdered, according to Japanese wartime records.
John Rabe, Chairman of the International Committee for the Nanking Safety Zone, estimated that 50,000 to 60,000 civilians were killed inside the city walls, though he could not see the whole city. Lewis S. C. Smythe, an American professor who was in Nanjing during the attack, surveyed the city and nearby areas in 1938. He recorded 12,000 civilians murdered inside the city walls and 26,780 killed in the surrounding countryside. Later, the 1947 verdict of the Nanjing War Crimes Tribunal reported more than 300,000 victims in total. Many modern historians think the figure of 300,000 civilian deaths is too high, and Ikuhiko Hata describes it as a "symbolic figure" of China's wartime suffering. Today, China officially uses the figure of 300,000, while the Japanese army's attack is often described as lasting from December 4, 1937, to March 28, 1938.
War crimes tribunals
After Japan surrendered, the main officers in charge of the Japanese troops at Nanjing were put on trial. General Matsui was charged before the International Military Tribunal for the Far East for ignoring his legal duty to take steps to stop breaches of the Hague Convention. Other leaders were not tried. Prince Kan'in Kotohito, chief of staff during the massacre, had died before the war ended in May 1945. Prince Asaka was granted immunity because he was a member of the imperial family. When SCAP officials questioned Prince Asaka, he denied that any massacre had happened.
Witnesses, including Robert O. Wilson, Miner Searle Bates, John Magee, George A. Fitch, and Lewis S. C. Smythe, helped the prosecution's case. Matsui said he had never ordered the killing of Chinese POWs and blamed his lower-ranking commanders. The court found him responsible for the crimes because he did nothing effective to stop them. Kōki Hirota was also convicted. On November 12, 1948, Matsui and Hirota were sentenced to death by hanging, and they were hanged on December 23, 1948. In China, Hisao Tani was tried by the Nanjing War Crimes Tribunal, found guilty, and executed in 1947. Historian Tokushi Kasahara later said the evidence against him was not entirely convincing and that a full investigation could have named other senior figures, including emperor Hirohito.
Memorials
In 1985, the Memorial Hall for Nanjing Massacre victims was built by the Nanjing Municipal Government to remember the victims and raise awareness of the massacre. It stands near a site where thousands of bodies were buried, called the "pit of ten thousand corpses" (Chinese: 万人坑; pinyin: Wàn rén kēng). As of December 2016, a memorial wall listed 10,615 victim names. In 1995, Daniel Kwan held a photo exhibit in Los Angeles titled "The Forgotten Holocaust." In 2005, John Rabe's former home in Nanjing was renovated and became the "John Rabe and International Safety Zone Memorial Hall," which opened in 2006.
On December 13, 2009, Chinese and Japanese monks held a religious gathering to mourn Chinese civilians killed by invading Japanese troops. On December 13, 2014, China held its first Nanjing Massacre Memorial Day. On October 9, 2015, documents of the Nanjing Massacre were listed on the UNESCO Memory of the World Register.
Controversy
Further information: Historiography of the Nanjing Massacre
Japanese historian Fujiwara Akira said that when Japan accepted the Potsdam Declaration and surrendered in August 1945, the state officially acknowledged the war of aggression and the Nanjing massacre. In Japan, views on the massacre were divided. One group accepts the findings of the Tokyo Trials and concludes that there were at least 200,000 casualties and at least 20,000 rape cases. The other group rejects those findings as "victor's justice." David Askew, a former professor, said the first group's view was more sophisticated and was supported by many experts. Tomio Hora, a professor at Waseda University, wrote a detailed book about the massacre in 1967. Later attempts to deny the massacre did not present enough evidence to succeed.
There are disputes about the death toll. Some estimates include 57,418 Chinese prisoners of war killed at Mufushan, though the latest research suggests between 4,000 and 20,000 were killed. Other estimates include 112,266 bodies buried by the Chongshantang charity, though some historians argue its records were greatly exaggerated or made up. Bob Wakabayashi estimated that fewer than 50,000 people died within the Nanjing City Wall, and that total victims in the city and surrounding rural counties were more than 100,000 but fewer than 200,000. Some Japanese politicians have expressed no remorse, which has worsened tensions in Sino-Japanese relations, and some officials and historians have denied or dismissed the massacre.
Legacy
Main article: Japanese history textbook controversies
The memory of the Nanjing Massacre has been a point of disagreement in Sino-Japanese relations since the early 1970s. Trade between the two nations is worth over $200 billion each year, but many Chinese people still feel distrust because of the massacre and because efforts at reconciliation have not worked. Japan's unwillingness to admit to and apologize for the atrocities makes this distrust stronger. Takashi Yoshida explained that the event has taken on different meanings for China, Japan, and the U.S., depending on each country's changing concerns and sense of "national interest." Many Japanese prime ministers have visited the Yasukuni Shrine, a shrine for Japanese war deaths up until the end of the Second World War, which includes war criminals involved in the massacre. In 2006, former prime minister Junichiro Koizumi visited the shrine despite warnings from China and South Korea, which caused international anger. Koizumi denied that he was trying to glorify war or historical Japanese militarism. The massacre is also compared with other disasters in China, including the Great Chinese famine (1959–1961) and the Cultural Revolution.
In China, the massacre strengthened the will to resist Japan's aggression. Before the 1970s, China did little to draw attention to it, and there was almost no public commemoration until after 1982. In her book, Iris Chang argued that Cold War politics encouraged Mao Zedong to stay quiet about Nanjing to keep trade with Japan. Jung Chang and Jon Halliday wrote in their biography of Mao that he never commented on the massacre, though he often spoke bitterly about his political struggle with Wang Ming in December 1937. In 1982, concerned with Japanese denialism, Chinese media published accounts of the massacre. According to Howard W. French, the massacre was not often mentioned in China because the communists preferred to promote the "martyrs of class struggles." Guo-Qiang Liu and Fengqi Qian of Deakin University say that since the 1990s, the massacre has become a national memory through the Patriotic Education Campaign, as part of the "Century of Humiliation." This story is closely tied to national identity in China. A film, Dead to Rights, was released in China in July 2025, and the newspaper China Daily said it was meant to "prevent amnesia" rather than spread animosity. In Japan, the novelist Yoshie Hotta wrote the novel Time in 1953, showing the massacre through the eyes of a Chinese intellectual, and some civil society groups have discussed the event. The Japanese government says that the killing of many noncombatants and looting by the army cannot be denied, but the number of victims is hard to determine. The Japanese Society for History Textbook Reform published a textbook that called the massacre an "incident," and it was used by only 13 schools. Also, dockworkers in Australia refused to load pig iron onto ships heading for Japan, which led to the Dalfram Dispute of 1938.
Records
In December 2007, the government of the People's Republic of China published the names of 13,000 people who were killed by Japanese troops in the Nanjing Massacre. According to Xinhua News Agency, it is the most complete record so far. The report has eight volumes and was released to mark the 70th anniversary of the start of the massacre. It also lists the Japanese army units responsible for each death and states how the victims were killed.
Zhang Xianwen, the editor-in-chief of the report, said the information was based on "a combination of Chinese, Japanese and Western raw materials," which he described as objective and fair. This report formed part of a 55-volume series about the massacre, called the Collection of Historical Materials of Nanjing Massacre (南京大屠杀史料集 pinyin: Nánjīng dà túshā shǐliào jí).
Pictures
Keep exploring
This article is a child-friendly adaptation of the Wikipedia article on Nanjing Massacre, available under CC BY-SA 4.0.
Images from Wikimedia Commons. Tap any image to view credits and license.
