Safekipedia

Lunar Laser Ranging experiments

Adventurer · ages 7–10Adapted from Wikipedia
The Lunar Laser Ranging Experiment left on the Moon by Apollo 11 astronauts, with a stereo camera in the background. Scientists on Earth still bounce laser light off this reflector to measure the distance between the Earth and the Moon.

Lunar Laser Ranging (LLR) is a way of measuring the distance between the surfaces of the Earth and the Moon using laser ranging. Scientists work out the distance by timing how long laser light takes to go to the Moon and come back. The light travels at the speed of light and bounces back to Earth from the Moon's surface or from one of several retroreflectors placed there.

Three retroreflectors were placed on the Moon by the United States' Apollo program, during the Apollo 11, Apollo 14, and Apollo 15 missions. The Soviet Lunokhod 1 and 2 missions placed two more, and India's Chandrayaan-3 mission placed one.

Lunar Laser Ranging Experiment from the 1969 Apollo 11 mission

Light or radio waves can also be bounced straight off the Moon's surface, a process known as EME. However, retroreflectors allow a much more exact measurement. Because they are small, the reflected signal spreads out much less over time. The light also comes back more evenly.

Laser ranging measurements can also be made with retroreflectors on Moon-orbiting satellites, such as the LRO.

History

Apollo 15 lunar laser ranging retroreflector

The first successful lunar ranging tests were carried out in 1962. Louis Smullin and Giorgio Fiocco from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology saw laser light bounce off the Moon's surface. Later that year, a Soviet team at the Crimean Astrophysical Observatory got similar results using a Q-switched ruby laser. Soon after, Princeton University graduate student James Faller suggested placing mirror-like reflectors on the Moon. This would make the measurements more accurate. The crew of Apollo 11 placed a reflector array on the Moon on July 21, 1969. Apollo 14 and Apollo 15 later left two more. On Aug. 1, 1969, the telescope at Lick Observatory first measured signals from these reflectors. Other observatories soon joined in. They included the Air Force Cambridge Research Laboratories Lunar Ranging Observatory in Arizona, the Pic du Midi Observatory in France, the Tokyo Astronomical Observatory, and the McDonald Observatory in Texas.

The uncrewed Soviet rovers Lunokhod 1 and Lunokhod 2 carried smaller arrays. In 2010, NASA's Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter found the Lunokhod 1 rover in photos. A team from the University of California then measured its array. The Apollo 15 array is three times the size of the earlier Apollo arrays. Newer technology now allows smaller arrays to be used more often. This happens at sites such as the Côte d'Azur Observatory in Nice, France, and the Apache Point Observatory Lunar Laser-ranging Operation (APOLLO) in New Mexico. New retroreflectors were planned in the 2010s. One was the MoonLIGHT reflector, which was going to travel to the Moon on the private MX-1E lander. That launch has since been canceled. In August 2023, India's Chandrayaan-3 lunar lander placed a sixth reflector on the Moon.

Principle

See also: Apache Point Observatory Lunar Laser-ranging Operation § Principles of operation

Annotated image of the near side of the Moon showing the location of retroreflectors left on the surface by Apollo and Lunokhod missions

We can roughly find the distance to the Moon by multiplying the speed of light by the time the light takes to reach the Moon and come back, then dividing by two. The speed of light is a fixed number, so time and distance can be converted exactly. A precise answer must consider many factors. These include the Moon's position in the sky, the movement of Earth and the Moon, Earth's spinning, lunar libration, polar motion, weather, how light slows down in the layers of the Earth atmosphere, where the observing station is and how it moves because of crustal motion and tides, and relativistic effects. The round trip takes about 2.5 seconds. The distance keeps changing, but on average it is about 385,000 km (239,000 mi) from the center of the Earth to the center of the Moon.

The laser beam is about 6.5 kilometers (4.0 mi) wide when it reaches the Moon. Scientists compare aiming it to shooting a rifle at a moving dime 3 kilometers (1.9 mi) away. The reflected light is too faint for our eyes to see. Only a tiny amount of the light sent at the reflector comes back to Earth, about 1 to 5 particles of light, even in good conditions. Scientists can still pick out this light because the laser light is made of just one colour (monochromatic). As of 2009, the distance to the Moon can be measured to the nearest millimeter. This makes it one of the most precise distance measurements ever made. It is as accurate as measuring the distance between Los Angeles and New York to within the width of a human hair.

List of retroreflectors

Main article: List of retroreflectors on the Moon

List of observatories

The table below shows Lunar Laser Ranging stations on Earth. Some of these stations are still working, and some have stopped.

Lunar Laser Ranging stations
ObservatoryProjectOperating timespanTelescopeLaserRange accuracy
McDonald Observatory, Texas, USMLRS1969–1985
1985–2013
2.7 m694 nm, 7 J
532 nm, 200 ps, 150 mJ
Crimean Astrophysical Observatory (CrAO), USSR1974, 1982–1984694 nm3.0–0.6 m
Côte d'Azur Observatory (OCA), Grasse, FranceMeO1984–1986
1986–2010
2010–present (2021)
694 nm
532 nm, 70 ps, 75 mJ
532/1064 nm
Haleakala Observatory, Hawaii, USLURE1984–1990532 nm, 200 ps, 140 mJ2.0 cm
Matera Laser Ranging Observatory (MLRO), Italy2003–present (2021)532 nm
Apache Point Observatory, New Mexico, USAPOLLO2006–2021
2021–present (2023)
532 nm, 100 ps, 115 mJ1.1 mm
Geodetic Observatory Wettzell, GermanyWLRS2018–present (2021)1064 nm, 10 ps, 75 mJ
Yunnan Astronomical Observatory, Kunming, China20181.2 m532 nm, 10 ns, 3 Jmeter level

Data analysis

Scientists collect Lunar Laser Ranging data to find numbers for several measurements. Studying this data involves the study of motion, along with the geology of Earth and the Moon. The work has two main parts. One part is figuring out the Moon's orbit and position very accurately. The other part is working out how long laser light takes to travel from a station on Earth to a retroreflector on the Moon and back. Modern data can be matched with an error of about 1 centimetre. A computer program calculates the distance between the centres of Earth and the Moon. The same program tracks how the Moon is turned, which is called physical Libration.

The model includes the station's position on Earth. That position can shift because of plate tectonics, Earth rotation, precession, nutation, and polar motion. The model also includes tides and seasonal movement of the solid Earth with respect to its center of mass. It accounts for effects of relativity on time and space, and for Lorentz contraction of the Moon. Other parts of the model cover the delay caused by Earth's atmosphere, the position of the retroreflector, and thermal expansion and contraction of the retroreflector mounts. For more details about the Earth model, the IERS Conventions (2010) is a useful source.

Results

Data from lunar laser ranging can be found at the Paris Observatory Lunar Analysis Center, the International Laser Ranging Service archives, and active stations. Some of the findings of this long-term experiment are about the Moon itself. Scientists can measure the distance to the Moon very precisely, to within a millimeter. The Moon is slowly moving away from Earth, about 3.8 cm each year, a rate that scientists have called unusually high. The Moon probably has a liquid core about 20% of its radius in size. The Moon also has librations that need one or more causes. Measurements also describe the core's flattening and its free nutation.

The experiments also teach scientists about gravity. Einstein's theory of gravity, the general theory of relativity, predicts the Moon's orbit to within the accuracy of the laser measurements. Gauge freedom plays a major role in understanding the relativity effects seen in the Earth-Moon system. A hypothetical effect called the Nordtvedt effect would be a small difference in how the Moon and Earth are pulled toward the Sun. Scientists have ruled it out to high precision. This strongly supports the strong equivalence principle. The pull of gravity is very stable. The experiments limit the change in Newton's gravitational constant G to a factor of (2±7)×10−13 per year.

Quiz time!

4 questions about Lunar Laser Ranging experiments

Question 1 of 4

How do scientists work out the distance to the Moon using laser ranging?

Pictures

A detailed photograph of the Full Moon, taken in 2010 from Madison, Alabama, USA, using a telescope and a camera. Many images were combined to make the picture clearer.
A laser ranging retroreflector left on the Moon by the Apollo 14 astronauts. Scientists still bounce lasers off devices like this to measure the distance between Earth and the Moon.
The Wettzell Laser Ranging System, which uses a large telescope in a dome to bounce laser pulses off satellites and the Moon to measure distances very precisely.
Green laser beams from NASA's Goddard Spaceflight Center reach up to the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter, helping scientists track satellites orbiting Earth and the Moon.
A montage of the planets in our solar system, from Mercury at the top to Neptune at the bottom, with images taken by NASA spacecraft. The planets are shown roughly to scale within the inner and outer groups.
A diagram showing when light particles, called photons, arrive from the Moon.

Keep exploring

This article is a child-friendly adaptation of the Wikipedia article on Lunar Laser Ranging experiments, available under CC BY-SA 4.0.

Images from Wikimedia Commons. Tap any image to view credits and license.