Fair trade
Fair trade is a trade arrangement designed to help producers in developing countries achieve sustainable and fair conditions. The fair trade movement supports paying higher prices to exporters and improving social and environmental standards. It focuses especially on products that are usually exported from developing countries to developed countries, but that are also sold within their home markets, such as handicrafts, coffee, cocoa, wine, sugar, fruit, flowers and gold.
Many fair trade labelling groups use a definition developed by FINE, an informal group of four international fair trade organizations: Fairtrade International (formerly called FLO, Fairtrade Labelling Organizations International), World Fair Trade Organization (WFTO), Network of European Worldshops and European Fair Trade Association (EFTA). By this definition, fair trade is a trading partnership based on dialogue, transparency and respect, which seeks greater fairness in international trade. Fair trade organizations, supported by consumers, help producers, raise awareness and campaign for changes to the rules and practices of conventional international trade. Fair trade certifiers include Fairtrade International, Ecocert, Fair World Project and Fair Trade USA. In 2008, Fairtrade International certified about €3.4 billion worth of products.
On 6 June 2008, Wales became the world's first Fair Trade Nation, and Scotland followed in February 2013. The movement is popular in the United Kingdom, which has over 500 Fairtrade towns, 118 universities, over 6,000 churches, and over 4,000 schools registered in the Fairtrade Schools Scheme. In 2011, more than 1.2 million farmers and workers in more than 60 countries took part in Fairtrade International's system, which paid €65 million in fairtrade premium to producers to use for developing their communities.
Some criticisms have been raised about fair trade. Critics say that fair trade certification has not led to financial benefits for producers or better working conditions, and that it has resulted in greater inequality in some markets. One proposed alternative is direct trade, which removes the overhead costs of fair trade certification and lets suppliers receive higher prices, closer to the retail value of the final product.
History
Main article: History of fair trade
In the 1940s and 1950s, religious groups and political non-governmental organizations (NGOs) in the global north began selling fair trade goods. Ten Thousand Villages, an NGO within the Mennonite Central Committee, and SERRV International were the first to build fair trade supply chains in developing countries, in 1946 and 1949. The products were mostly handicrafts, from jute goods to cross-stitch work, and were often sold in churches or fairs. The fair trade movement took shape in Europe in the 1960s, and its slogan "Trade not Aid" was adopted by the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) in 1968. In 1965, the British NGO Oxfam launched "Helping-by-Selling," and in 1969 the first worldshop opened in the Netherlands. Similar shops soon opened in the Benelux countries, Germany, and other Western European countries.
In the early 1980s, alternative trading organizations faced challenges as handicrafts sales slowed. Fair trade supporters began to focus more on farm products, such as commodity goods, which later helped many of these organizations grow. Sales of fair trade products grew much more after the first Fairtrade certification initiatives appeared. In 1988, Max Havelaar was created in the Netherlands by Nico Roozen, Frans Van Der Hoff, and Solidaridad. Its labeling initiative let fair trade goods be sold in regular stores and helped shoppers check that producers were benefiting. Later, Starbucks began offering fair trade coffee in 2000, and other large companies such as Sara Lee Corporation, Procter & Gamble (the maker of Folgers), Nestlé, and The Hershey Company also started selling fair trade products. Some activists argued that these products made only a small difference for small farmers.
| Business type | Engagement with fair trade products |
|---|---|
| Highest | |
| Fair trade organizations | Equal Exchange |
| Global Crafts | |
| Ten Thousand Villages | |
| Values-driven organizations | The Body Shop |
| Green Mountain Coffee | |
| Pro-active socially responsible businesses | Starbucks |
| Whole Foods The Ethical Olive | |
| Defensive socially responsible businesses | Procter & Gamble |
| Lowest |
Organizations promoting fair trade
Main article: Worldshop
Main article: Alternative trading organization
Many groups promote fair trade. They include product certifiers, organization certifiers, alternative trading organizations, shops, education groups, student groups, religious groups, and universities. Most fair trade importers belong to, or are certified by, one of several federations that coordinate and support fair trade work. Product certifiers include Fairtrade International, created in 1997, which runs the Fair trade Certification Mark and is the largest certifier of labeled Fair trade. Fair Trade USA, founded in 1998, is another nonprofit certifier, and Ecocert also certifies fair trade labels. The World Fair Trade Organization, created in 1989, certifies organizations rather than products. The Network of European Worldshops became its European chapter in 2008.
Importer and retailer groups include the European Fair Trade Association, created in 1990, and the Fair Trade Federation, created in 1994 in Canada and the United States. Global Goods Partners, founded in 2005, supports women-led cooperatives in the developing world. Worldshops, which are often not-for-profit and run by volunteers, sell fair trade products and aim to pay producers in a developing country a fair price. Many are based in Europe, but they also exist in industrialized countries such as North America, Australia, and New Zealand. Examples of alternative trading organizations include Equal Exchange Trading, Traidcraft, and Twin Trading. Church groups have also long supported fair trade, such as Ten Thousand Villages. The idea of a Fair Trade school or university began in the United Kingdom. In the United States, the University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh became an early example, and the University of California, San Diego became the second Fair Trade University in the country in 2010. In 1998, four federations, including Fairtrade International, joined together as FINE to harmonize standards. A Fair Trade town is a town that meets some fair trade criteria. Make Trade Fair is no longer active.
Product certification
Note: Customary spelling of Fairtrade is one word when referring to the FLO product labeling system. See Fairtrade certification
Fairtrade labelling, usually called Fair Trade Certified in the United States, helps shoppers identify goods that meet certain standards. Fairtrade International sets the standards, and FLO-CERT is the certification body that checks producers and traders through independent auditing. To carry a certification mark, a product must come from certified producer organizations, and its supply chain must be monitored. The system aims to guarantee fair prices and ethical buying practices. These include banning child labour and slave labour, providing safe workplaces and the right to unionise, following the United Nations charter of human rights, paying a fair price that covers production costs, and protecting the environment. It also encourages long-term business relationships between buyers and sellers.
Fairtrade certification covers a growing range of products, such as bananas, coffee, sugar, tea, and wine. Companies that meet the standards can apply for licences to use the Fairtrade marks. The International Fairtrade Certification Mark was launched in 2002 by FLO and replaced twelve older marks. It is used worldwide except in the United States, where the Fair Trade Certified Mark is still used. Coffee cooperatives must be certified, and buyers pay them an extra 10c per pound for community development projects. Cooperatives use this money for certification costs and social projects such as schools and health clinics. Many complaints about the standards not being enforced appear in the fair trade debate.
System
Many fair trade and ethical marketing groups use different marketing strategies. Most fair trade sellers believe they need to sell their products in supermarkets to get enough trade to help the developing world. In 2018, nearly 700,000 metric tons of fair-trade bananas were sold worldwide. Next came cocoa beans (260,000 tons) and coffee beans (207,000 tons). The biggest product by number of units was fair-trade flowers, with over 825 million units sold.
Many fair trade groups still follow the original goals of fair trade. They sell their products through other channels where they can, and through special fair trade shops. However, they make up only a small part of the whole market compared to Fairtrade International.
Effect on growers
Fair trade helps workers in developing countries, and its effects differ from place to place. In a study of 34 coffee growers in Guatemala, most knew something about fair trade, but only three understood both how fair markets work and how fair trade affects their communities. Those three had jobs within their cooperatives. Many farmers joined for reasons other than a better price, such as switching to organic farming, raising money for community projects, and getting more training. Farmers in Peru said fair trade helped their families and communities, though some still wanted higher prices to live better lives.
Fair trade also brings indirect benefits. Fair trade cooperatives create a sense of teamwork and encourage growers to run their own businesses. The extra money buyers pay, called the "social premium," is usually spent on community needs, and groups decide together how to use it. Many groups spend it on public goods such as schools, water projects, and environmental work. Some use it for scholarships. For example, the Costa Rican coffee cooperative Coocafé has helped hundreds of children and young people go to school and university. Other groups put the money back into their farms and businesses, such as buying trucks, machinery, or training for their members.
Psychology
People who buy fair trade products usually choose to do so on purpose. Their choice is shaped by their attitude, their moral norms, how much control they feel they have, and social norms. Adding moral norms helps predict whether someone will intend to buy fair trade, beyond the basic factors of attitude and feeling in control.
University students have greatly increased how much fair trade products they buy over the last several decades. Women college students have a more favorable attitude than men toward buying fair trade products, and they feel more morally obligated to do so. Women are also reported to have stronger intentions to buy them. Producers seek fair trade certification for several reasons, including religious ties, a desire for social justice, a desire for independence, political change, or simply wanting to be paid more for their work and products. Farmers are more likely to identify with organic farming than with fair trade farming practices, because organic farming visibly sets them apart from their neighbors and shapes how they farm. They value natural growing methods. Fair trade farmers also tend to credit their higher prices to the quality of their products, rather than to fair market prices.
World wide
Sales of Fair Trade products grow by close to 30% each year. In 2004 they were worth over US$500 million, and by 2008 global sales of fairtrade products had passed US$3.5 billion. In some countries, coffee sales grow by nearly 50% per year. In 2002, consumers bought 16,000 tons of Fairtrade coffee in 17 countries. Fair trade coffee is grown in 24 countries in Latin America, Africa, and Asia. Most fair trade products are made in the South and bought in the North, and people disagree about whether buying these products really helps southern countries grow. In Africa, global supply chain work is growing, and Africa is known for tea, cocoa, flowers, and wine. Cocoa growers in West Africa often form cooperatives, such as Kuapa Kokoo in Ghana. Cocoa quality can fall in countries like Cameroon, Nigeria, and the Ivory Coast, which do not have strong fair trade industries.
In Latin America, studies in the early 2000s found that coffee producers in Fair Trade had better income, education, and health than producers who were not part of it. Latin America also exports many fair trade bananas. The Dominican Republic is the largest producer, followed by Mexico, Ecuador, and Costa Rica. In Chile, Fundación Solidaridad was created to help handicraft producers earn more and take part in their communities. In Asia, garment factories in China, Burma, and Bangladesh are often accused of human rights problems, including child labour, which go against fair trade principles. Fairtrade India was set up in 2013 in Bangalore, in India. In Australia, the Fair Trade Association of Australia and New Zealand supports two fair trade systems.
Commodities
Fair trade commodities are goods that are certified by a fair trade organization, such as Fair Trade USA. These organizations are usually overseen by Fairtrade International, which sets fair trade standards and supports producers and cooperatives. Most of the fair trade market is food, such as coffee, tea, cocoa, honey, and bananas. Crafts, textiles, and flowers are also traded. Coffee is the most established fair trade product, and most of it is Coffea arabica. Fair trade coffee producers are grouped into cooperatives, and buyers pay them at least a minimum fair price. In cocoa, fair trade cooperatives such as Kuapa Kokoo in Ghana help farmers get a fair price. The Harkin–Engel Protocol, negotiated by Tom Harkin, is an agreement meant to end some of the worst forms of child labor in the cocoa industry. Fair trade cotton is the main fiber for fair trade textiles, and fair trade certification also covers seafood, flowers, and precious metals such as gold.
Fair trade does not always help everyone equally. Coffee growers' incomes depend on market prices, and studies have noted that workers on some Fairtrade farms have a lower standard of living than similar farms outside the system. Fair trade textiles also face challenges, since cotton from Burkina Faso and Mali has seen power imbalances continue even after certification. Even so, fair trade is growing quickly, and cooperatives often give women a voice in their communities.
Politics
See also: Protectionism and Dumping (pricing policy)
Support for fair trade grew in the European Union over many years. In 1994, the European Commission said it supported fair trade, and the European Parliament voiced its support too. In 1996, the Economic and Social Committee (EESC) gave its opinion on the fair trade marking movement. In 2000, public institutions in Europe began buying Fairtrade Certified coffee and tea, the Cotonou Agreement mentioned promoting fair trade, and the European Parliament and Council Directive 2000/36/EC also suggested promoting it. In 2004, the European Union adopted a proposal that praised the fair trade movement. In 2006, the European Parliament unanimously adopted a resolution on fair trade. Green politician Frithjof Schmidt said it responded to the growth of fair trade, and Peter Mandelson, EU Commissioner for External Trade, said it would help the Commission build a coherent policy.
Several countries also took action. In France, French National Assembly member Antoine Herth issued a report with 40 proposals to support fair trade in 2005, and a law was passed to set up a commission to recognize fair trade organisations. In 2006, the French chapter of ISO (AFNOR) adopted a reference document on fair trade. In Italy, lawmakers debated a fair trade law in 2006, and a definition was developed, but the law was stalled by the 2008 Italian political crisis. In the Netherlands, coffee supplier Douwe Egberts sued the Dutch province of Groningen in 2007 over its fair trade requirements for coffee suppliers. After several months of discussions and legal challenges, the province of Groningen prevailed.
Criticism
Some studies say fair trade is helpful and efficient, while others are less positive. Some criticism is about fair trade itself, and sometimes its results depend on wider factors, such as a lack of government help or prices that change quickly on the global market. A 2015 study concluded that producers gained almost nothing, because too many products were certified and only a small part was sold as fair trade. A study in the Journal of Economic Perspectives found that fair trade reaches many of its goals, but on a fairly small scale. A 2014 study of coffee and tea producers in Uganda and Ethiopia suggested that joining fair trade groups did not improve workers' conditions.
Critics also say that little of the extra money paid by shoppers reaches farmers. Some believe fair trade can harm farmers who are not part of it, because higher prices may lead to too much production and falling prices. Others complain that the fair trade rules are not always enforced. Some critics think fair trade works inside the current trading system, including with large multinational corporations, instead of creating a new and fairer system.

Quiz time!
5 questions about Fair trade
What is the main goal of fair trade?
Pictures
Keep exploring
This article is a child-friendly adaptation of the Wikipedia article on Fair trade, available under CC BY-SA 4.0.
Images from Wikimedia Commons. Tap any image to view credits and license.